Faith and Health Summit 2022 Mindful Together
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

NC Council of Churches

Strength in Unity, Peace through Justice

  • Voices
  • About
    • Overview
    • Staff
    • Members
    • Covenant Partners
    • Issue Statements
    • Governing Board
    • Careers
  • Programs
    • NC Interfaith Power & Light
      • NCIPL Overview
      • Faith in Action NCIPL
      • NCIPL Articles
      • NCIPL Resources
      • Upcoming Events for NCIPL
      • Contact NCIPL
    • Partners in Health & Wholeness
      • PHW Staff
      • Mini-Grants
      • PHW Collaborative Pledge
      • Faith and Health Summit 2022 Mindful Together
      • The Overdose Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
      • Mental Health Advocacy
      • BIPOC Mental Health Grant
      • Growing Communities of Inclusion: A Faithful Response to HIV
      • Healthy Aging
      • Citizen Science
      • PHW Articles
      • FAQs
  • Priorities
    • Racial Justice
    • The Overdose Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
    • Gun Violence Prevention
    • Criminal Justice
    • Immigrant Rights
    • Public Education
    • Farmworkers
    • Legislative Advocacy
    • Christian Unity
    • Peace
  • Events
  • Resources
    • COVID-19 Resources
    • Publications & Reports
    • Raleigh Report
    • Lectionary
    • Sermons
  • Donate
  • Council Store
  • Show Search

Search NC Council of Churches

Hide Search

Legislators to Take Up Voter ID

Aleta Payne, Former Deputy Executive Director · March 15, 2011 · Leave a Comment

BY ROB CHRISTENSEN, The News & Observer

RALEIGH — Few issues so starkly divide red and blue America than proposals to require voters to produce photographic identification when they go the polls – a debate that is set to begin this week in the North Carolina legislature.

Republican lawmakers, who are championing the measure, argue that it is a common-sense idea to ensure the integrity of the voting process. Democrats see it as an effort to suppress voter turnout for narrow partisan gain.

“This is the first step toward restoring trust in government,” said Rep. Ric Killian, a Republican from Charlotte, who is expected to introduce a bill this week to require voter photo IDs.

“Elections are the beginning of the governmental process,” Killian said. “Most people believe there is a void in confidence in government and there is a void in confidence in the election process. Ensuring that a person is who they say they are is a crucial first step toward validating elections.”

But state Democratic Chairman David Parker of Statesville sees the legislation as an effort to disenfranchise between 600,000 to 1million North Carolina voters who do not hold driver’s licenses.

“Why the Republican Party wants to dishonor the flag and the principles of the Constitution is beyond me,” Parker said.

Much of the debate over the planned bill has centered on the extent of voter fraud in North Carolina and whether requiring photo IDs would be a hardship for some voters.

According to the N.C. Board of Elections, there have been few instances of serious voter fraud referred to the district attorney’s office for prosecution – 12 in 2002, 37 in 2004, seven in 2005, two in 2006. Voter fraud is a felony in North Carolina.

In 2008, which saw a sharp rise in voting when 4.2 million North Carolinians went to the polls, there were 235 voting felonies, 30 cases of double voting, 23 cases of noncitizens voting, five cases of absentee voting fraud and 16 cases of fraudulent registration forms turned over to the district attorney, according to the elections board.

Like everything else in politics, the statistics are used by both parties to spin their arguments. For the Democrats data is evidence that there is no widespread fraud in North Carolina. For Republicans, it only proves that the Democratic-controlled state and local boards of elections are not catching the fraud.

“I have heard many, many stories about voter fraud,” said Killian. “Most recently I heard in Washington County where four dead people voted in a sheriff’s race. I believe there are cases of voter fraud, and I believe there are cases that are reported that are not investigated.”

Johnnie McLean, deputy director of the State Board of Elections, said the story, which has been widely circulated in conservative circles, isn’t true. The confusion arose over a clerical error, she said. On Election Day, voters pointed out four relatives who had died and who advised poll workers that their names should be should be stricken from the rolls. Their names were inadvertently put in a voter history list file but no ballot was cast in their names.

Francis De Luca, executive director of the Civitas Institute, a Raleigh conservative think tank, said public opinion polls show 84 percent of North Carolina voters support requiring photo identification, which cuts across partisan and racial lines.

“The fact that people think it’s needed is a reason why it’s needed,” De Luca said. “If there is ever a close election in North Carolina it will be assured that everyone who has voted will be who they say they are. It will help cut down on questions about the outcome of elections.”

De Luca said numerous trends argue for photo IDs including larger precincts where election officials are less likely to know the voters, and one-stop voting where people register and vote on the same day.

“In North Carolina history there have been numerous cases where there have been voter fraud,” De Luca said. “I don’t believe it is widespread, but it does exist.”

But Democrats say if there is perception of voter fraud in North Carolina, it exists mainly in Republican circles rather than in reality. And they argue that the concern seems to have grown after the strong turnout of African-Americans and young voters for Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama in 2008.

At a panel discussion on the voter ID bill at Raleigh’s Temple Beth Orr last week, Bill Wilson, an advocate for the state AARP chapter, said there were efforts to suppress the turnout in the African-American community in North Carolina back in the 1990s.

“That is clearly the intent here again,” Wilson said. “It is hard to say this is to cure a problem when the problem doesn’t exist.”

Such a law is expected to affect people who don’t hold driver’s licenses – the elderly who no longer drive, the poor who cannot afford cars, the handicapped who can’t drive, and perhaps some young people who don’t have a driver’s license.

But exactly how many of North Carolina’s 6.1 million registered voters would be affected is unclear.

Those without licenses

The State Board of Elections recently matched voter records with those of the Division of Motor Vehicles and found that 556,513 voters do not hold driver’s licenses. It also found 329,017 voters whose licenses had been revoked or expired, and 114,417 names where there was not a complete match between the names on the voting and DMV records.

But Republicans say that even if people don’t have a driver’s license, they have some sort of photo ID. They cite a statewide poll conducted in December by the Civitas Institute of 600 voters that found that 99 percent of those asked said they had some form of photo ID.

A 2008 survey of 2,000 people in three states – Indiana, Maryland and Mississippi – found that only 1 percent of registered voters said they did not have a photo ID. The survey was conducted by the American University’s Center for Democracy & Election Management.

Critics say they anticipate problems.

Wilson of the AARP said it would be a major hardship for senior citizens who no longer drive. To obtain a nondriver photo ID from the DMV costs $10 and requires proof of identity such as a Social Security card and a proof of residency such as a utility bill.

At the Raleigh forum last week, George Reed of the N.C. Council of Churches recalled that in 2008, 12 retired nuns from Saint Mary’s Convent in South Bend, Ind., were turned away at a voting place in their own convent because they lacked a state or federal photo ID that is required under Indiana’s law.

Groups representing young people are also concerned that out-of-state driver’s licenses or student IDs would not be accepted.

“North Carolina has a huge population of students who are not from the state of North Carolina,” said Heather Smith, president of Rock the Vote, a nonpartisan voter organization active on Triangle campuses. “They have a constitutional right to vote there. But they do not have a North Carolina driver’s license, or if they do it might not match their exact dorm address.”

Wendy Weiser, a voting rights expert with the Brennan Center for Justice at New York University, said there have been few reliable studies of what impact voter ID requirements have had on voter participation because so many variables affect turnout.

But the requirement is almost certain to cost the state money.

It cost Missouri $6 million the first year, and it cost Indiana $3.3 million, according to the Brennan Center.

The problem, said state Rep. Mickey Michaux of Durham, is that hundreds of thousands of people without driver’s licenses would have to have state-issued photo IDs.

“If you charge people a fee, you are basically creating a poll tax,” Michaux said. “If you are going to do it with state funds, you don’t know what it’s going to cost. Even for the folks where you provide the ID for free, folks are not going to be able to go to the places you go to get them because of their age. ”

But Killian, the bill’s chief sponsor, said most people should be able to get a photo ID. “It is not the intent of anyone I have talked to to discourage anyone from voting,” Killian said. “That is absolutely not the intent.”

rob.christensen@newsobserver.com or 919-829-4532

Filed Under: In the Media Tagged With: Civil Liberties, Good Government

About Aleta Payne, Former Deputy Executive Director

Aleta Payne first joined the Council staff in the spring of 2001 as the Communications Associate. She continues to oversee that work along with development, represents the Council in several partnership efforts, and serves in other administrative roles, as well. Aleta is a graduate of the University of Virginia with a degree in government and foreign affairs and spent much of her early career as a journalist. She has three young adult sons who continue to come home to Cary for dinner, or at least groceries, and two young adult terrier-mix dogs who keep the nest from feeling too empty.

Reader Interactions

More Like This

Defenders of Rights; Defenders of Privilege
Regaining our Faith in Democracy
Rights Advocacy At Risk

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Footer

Contact

NC Council of Churches
27 Horne St.
Raleigh, NC 27607
(919) 828-6501
info@ncchurches.org

Facebook

Partners in Health and Wholeness

Featured

Legislators to Take Up Voter ID

Latest Tweets

Ever wonder what the process is for counting ballots and securing elections in NC? Join one of the town halls in the NC Trusted Elections Tour and find out how well prepared our elections workers are! More info soon: charlotteledger.subs…

About 12 hours ago

Read about why a robust carbon plan could put North Carolina at the forefront of clean energy in the U.S. and set a standard that other states could follow! We are at a pivotal moment! Learn more about the carbon plan here: ncchurches.org/2022/…

About 2 days ago

Join us today at 5:30 in Raleigh for a vigil outside commemorating the 16th anniversary of North Carolina’s last execution. We will remember the 43 people executed under our current death penalty law. nccadp.org/event/vig…

About 2 days ago

Like it or not – and there are plenty of reasons to worry amid the familiar end-of-summer bursts of excitement – another school year will soon get underway. Read more at ncchurches.org/2022/…

About 6 days ago

Using our voices to fulfill our civic duty and vote in every election makes a difference in our communities. This reflection guide with suggested questions to guide your conversations and spark ideas for questions to ask political candidates. ncchurches.org/2022/…

Last week

Follow @ncchurches

Latest Tweets

Join us for our Faith and Health Summit! Our theme for this year’s summit is Mindful Together. We want to acknowledge the need for mindful moments that hold our minds, bodies, & spirits bit.ly/FaithHealth20… pic.twitter.com/pfPa…

About 2 days ago

RT @ncchurches Join us for our @healthandfaith Faith and Health Summit! Our theme for this year’s summit is Mindful Together. We want to acknowledge the need for mindful moments that hold our minds, bodies, & spirits. Join us and a well-rounded list of expert speakers: ncchurches.ourpowerb… pic.twitter.com/WSnA…

Last week

Do you know what grant is right for your faith community? Check out the graphic below to learn about the differences between grants. Click here to learn more informationhttps://www.ncchurches.org/programs/phw/phw-mini-grants/ pic.twitter.com/umXb…

About 2 weeks ago

RT @FaithCompassWFU If we look at the HIV epidemic as an opportunity to bring healing, justice, and equity to those who have been marginalized and impacted by the health industry and society at large, we can generate more good in our communities. #breakthestigma #faithcompassWFU pic.twitter.com/FPIB…

About 3 weeks ago

RT @ncchurches This month we are excited to announce our @healthandfaith Interim Co-Directors: Jessica Stokes & Nicole Johnson. Jessica & Nicole have dedicated their hard work to supporting faith communities across NC. They will continue to do this work while overseeing the PHW program. pic.twitter.com/SU8Q…

About 3 weeks ago

Follow @healthandfaith

Latest Tweets

RT @interfaithpower @NCIPL organized a 190-person human prayer chain in Raleigh, NC. #Faiths4Climate #GetClimateDone twitter.com/NCIPL/st…

About 7 hours ago

RT @CPRBlog With our partner @NCIPL, we are calling on @DukeEnergy and the North Carolina Utilities Commission to ensure low-wealth ratepayers aren't left in the dark in the state's decarbonization plan. progressivereform.or…

About 7 hours ago

RT @averydavislamb I truly can't wait for this event next week. Lots of incredible speakers including @rickspinradnoaa, @GullahGeechee, @ewirzba, @mtmalcom! Plus, with @NCIPL, @GeorgiaIPL, @TXImpact, @AlabamaPJC, & @scinterfaith all on board, it's bound to be amazing. secure.everyaction.c…

About 7 hours ago

RT @interfaithpower 🧵1/The Senate voted to pass the single biggest climate & clean energy investment in our nation’s history! Read statements on the passage from the IPL network: interfaithpowerandli… #Faiths4Climate #GetClimateDone

Last week

RT @interfaithpower Join us tomorrow for a discussion about encouraging our #faith communities to #vote by offering sermons, divrei Torah, and khutbahs on the importance of #voting. Register at ow.ly/W6so50K5kqI #FaithClimateJusticeVoter #Vote2022 #VoteReady #Faiths4Climate #interfaith pic.twitter.com/6Ecw…

Last week

Follow @ncipl

Latest Tweets

Copyright © 2022 NC Council of Churches · All Rights Reserved · Website by Tomatillo Design · Hosted by WP Engine