Black Lives Matter.
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

NC Council of Churches

Strength in Unity, Peace through Justice

  • Voices
  • About
    • Overview
    • Staff
    • Members
    • Covenant Partners
    • Issue Statements
    • Governing Board
  • Programs
    • Ecumenical Immigration Alliance
      • Ideas for Action
      • Sign Our Statement
      • The NC Sanctuary Coalition
      • Immigration Bible Study
      • Contact
    • NC Interfaith Power & Light
      • NCIPL Overview
      • Faith in Action NCIPL
      • NCIPL Articles
      • NCIPL Resources
      • Upcoming Events for NCIPL
      • Contact NCIPL
    • Partners in Health & Wholeness
      • PHW Staff
      • Mini-Grants
      • PHW Collaborative Pledge
      • The Overdose Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
      • PHW Articles
      • FAQs
  • Priorities
    • Racial Justice
    • The Overdose Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
    • Gun Violence Prevention
    • Public Education
    • NC Sanctuary Coalition
    • Farmworkers
    • Legislative Advocacy
    • Christian Unity
    • Peace
    • NC No Torture
  • COVID-19 Resources
  • Events
  • Resources
    • Publications & Reports
    • Raleigh Report
    • Lectionary
    • Sermons
  • Donate
  • Council Store
  • Show Search

Search NC Council of Churches

Hide Search

Raleigh Report: Flawed deal to resurrect Silent Sam

Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate · December 13, 2019 · 2 Comments

Click here to sign up to receive the Raleigh Report in your inbox

When leaders of the N.C. Council of Churches two years ago adopted a policy statement entitled “Confederate-themed monuments: Time to reassess,” the statue known as Silent Sam still faced north in a prime spot on the Chapel Hill campus of the nation’s oldest public university.

But the image of a youthful soldier – cast as a tribute to University of North Carolina students who fought and in many cases died for the South in the Civil War – was emerging at the center of a raging debate over how to treat monuments honoring a cause rooted in the defense of slavery.

The Council’s Governing Board noted what it termed an inescapable truth: “Monuments that have the effect of glorifying the South’s Lost Cause and of venerating those who were its defenders must be seen as sympathetic to, or at the least heedless of, the racial oppression that the Confederacy was dedicated to upholding.”

The board called for “a re-examination of the roles of civic images hearkening back to an era when racial injustice was our state’s official policy – a policy so deeply ingrained that torrents of blood were spilled to defend it and to defeat it.”

By Aug. 20, 2018, such a re-examination of Silent Sam was well underway but mired in dispute among university leaders, legislators, the governor’s office, anti-white supremacy activists and neo-Confederate apologists. Protesters who for months had sought the statue’s removal – with no significant progress – took matters into their own hands and unlawfully pulled it down. Reassess this, they seemed to say.

Who would have imagined that, with the connivance of UNC-Chapel Hill’s university system overlords, the last word and a boast of victory would be granted to none other than the Sons of Confederate Veterans? Granted, that is, unless a secretive and slippery deal’s understandably outraged opponents somehow manage to roll it back. 

McCorkle’s guardian

A committee of the UNC system’s Board of Governors, tasked with figuring out what to do with the statue that had been hidden away in storage since it was toppled, fended off the predictable calls to re-erect it on leafy McCorkle Place where it had stood for 105 years.

Its location had seemed to make Silent Sam a sentinel guarding the Chapel Hill campus from Northern invaders and, eventually, from civil rights sympathizers. That no doubt would have suited the United Daughters of the Confederacy, who sponsored the statue and others like it. The group’s implicit goal was to depict the South’s doomed war effort as a noble defense of home and hearth instead of a desperate attempt to sustain a social system dependent on monstrous oppression of African-Americans. 

A compromise plan floated by then-Chancellor Carol Folt to keep the statue on campus, displayed in a new history center, had fizzled amid opposition to an ongoing campus presence. Folt announced last January that she planned to quit after her surprise decision to have the statue’s pedestal with its cringe-worthy pro-Confederate plaques dismantled – a decision that led the Board of Governors to tell her to go ahead and clear out.

But the board’s aforementioned committee – which could have chosen among many ways to treat the statue as a significant artifact while removing it as a source of conflict at UNC-Chapel Hill – angled for a plan guaranteed to turn up the heat even more. 

In a closely choreographed series of legally and ethically dubious moves that oozed contempt for Silent Sam’s critics, the committee on Nov. 27 managed to reach a court-approved deal giving the statue to a high-profile “Southern heritage” group.

Not only do the Sons of Confederate Veterans (SCV) stand to claim the statue, but they also are in line to receive $2.5 million from UNC-Chapel Hill to finance a display facility. The regional office of the Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights Under Law laid out a blistering analysis of the deal’s legal and procedural shortcomings that could and should lay the basis for scuttling it.

Meanwhile, state Attorney General Josh Stein was among those making the obvious point that the university could put the money to far better use in line with its educational mission. Stein’s next step should be clear: Instruct the Board of Governors to hit the brakes.

The SCV’s North Carolina division president, Kevin Stone, told members in a letter (accessible via the above link) that he envisions using the payout also to build a new headquarters.

“What we have accomplished is something that I never dreamed we could accomplish in a thousand years and all at the expense of the University itself,” Stone wrote after the deal was finalized. “This is a major strategic victory, and I look forward to continuing to move the Division forward.” That’s not exactly what those who view the SCV as perpetuators of white supremacist ideology in the guise of ancestor worship want to encourage – especially with the university system’s collaboration.

Echoes of Charlottesville

The Council of Churches’ effort to address how Confederate monuments should fit into today’s civic and cultural landscape, given evolving perspectives on the consequences of racism, followed the events of August 2017 in Charlottesville, Va. 

City officials’ decision to remove a statue of horse-mounted Gen. Robert E. Lee – a decision reflecting shock at the recent murder of black church members in Charleston, S.C., by a white-supremacist sociopath — led to a “Unite the Right” rally of white supremacists and neo-Nazis.

Activists from across the ideological divide rallied in opposition. One of them was killed when she was struck by a car that a white supremacy sympathizer drove into a crowd. Clearly, the mix of emotions stirred by Confederate statues and monuments could flare into violence.

But the risk to public safety was far from the whole problem. Pro-Confederate monuments and mythologizing had surged during the early years of the 20th century, in tandem with the tightening of strict Jim Crow laws solidifying African-Americans’ status as second-class citizens. These artifacts thus became enduring symbols of one of the United States’ most shameful chapters.

From the Council’s perspective, with its concern for the marginalized in keeping with Scriptural teachings, there emerged a duty to reassess the monuments so as not to endorse, explicitly or implicitly, the kind of discrimination they evoked.

The Council thus backed Gov. Roy Cooper’s call for repeal of a 2015 law enacted by the Republican-controlled General Assembly that was intended to keep local communities or institutions from relocating, phasing out or otherwise demoting Confederate “objects of remembrance.” That very law, as it happens, prevented UNC-Chapel Hill leaders from removing Silent Sam in orderly fashion because they thought it would be in the public interest. A mob paid the law no never-mind.

“Monuments given civic pride of place should reflect our most treasured values – and not those treasured by one segment of the public while loathed by another,” the Council’s governors stated. “They should be values at the foundation of our democracy – perhaps none so important as that all of us are created equal and are equally entitled to the privileges and protections of citizenship.” 

Equal protection and equal opportunity under the law indeed are supposed to lie at the very heart of America’s democratic system. Surely they are essential to protecting those who must struggle to overcome the sorry legacy of racial bigotry that still shadows many of our fellow citizens. Any outcome in the Silent Sam saga that seems to excuse or overlook that discrimination must be judged as failing to meet the Council’s standards while also betraying ideals that should be fundamental to our university system and to our elected leaders.

Filed Under: Blog, Homepage Featured, Raleigh Report Tagged With: Civil Discourse, Good Government, Race/Ethnicity

Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate

About Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate

Much goes on in North Carolina's state capital that's important to the Council of Churches. I'm glad to have a chance to help follow the action, transitioning from my career with The News & Observer of Raleigh, where I retired in 2012 as editorial page editor. I'm originally from Virginia but have lived in Cary so long I remember the Kildaire Farm barn.

Read more of my commentary here.

Reader Interactions

More Like This

Raleigh Report: Sidetrack for photo voter ID
Path to Fairer Maps, Better Government
Time to Take a Knee

Comments

  1. AvatarMarvin Maddox says

    December 13, 2019 at 11:37 am

    I agree with Steve Ford. I grew up in north Georgia a long time ago. It’s best to remember the past so we don’t repeat it. However, having these Confederate statues does not just remind us of the past, it honors the past: a sorry past. It’s embarrassing that we are now going to use NC taxpayers’ money to fund the work of the Sons of Confederate Veterans as they strive to honor this sorry past. Of course, if they wanted to use this money to make amends for the evils of slavery, that would be a different matter! Let’s move forward to a better future where all people are created equal.

    Incidentally, I’ve lived in Germany and visited much of the western portion of Germany and I’ve never seen any memorials to Adolph Hitler or the German soldiers who fought in the Second World War.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Anonymous comments or comments that target individuals will not be posted (please include your first and last name). All comments must be on topic and respectful. Comments will not be posted until they have been reviewed by a moderator. Comments do not reflect the positions of the NC Council of Churches.

Footer

Contact

NC Council of Churches
27 Horne St.
Raleigh, NC 27607
(919) 828-6501
info@ncchurches.org

Facebook

Partners in Health and Wholeness

Featured

Raleigh Report: Flawed deal to resurrect Silent Sam

Latest Tweets

Sign the @afsc_org petition calling on the Biden administration to keep Homestead child detention center in Florida closed! Follow the link to take action >> afsc.org/action/take…

Yesterday

Exciting Event! Register now for the screening of the short documentary: "Braided Prayer." The film tells the story of Abraham Jam, an interfaith folk/world music trio making the case that harmony can be even stronger than unity. Featuring @DavidLaMotte >> crowdcast.io/e/85zwf…

About 2 days ago

Recently, the Biden Administration has opened up HealthCare.gov until May 15th to give people who need health insurance a new opportunity to get covered through the Affordable Care Act (ACA) marketplace. Make sure to visit now to get covered!

About 2 days ago

Just last week, our Governing Board adopted a resolution calling for the removal of Confederate symbols in public squares. As people of faith & conscience, we believe such monuments are a constant reminder of prejudice against black and brown people. >> ncchurches.org/2021/… pic.twitter.com/iGCX…

About 5 days ago

"Amanda Gorman in her inauguration poem 'The Hill We Climb' begins with the lines: 'When day comes we ask ourselves where can we find light in this never-ending shade?'" Read more of this 2nd Sunday lenten reflection from Elizabeth Brewington >> ncchurches.org/2021/… pic.twitter.com/pgge…

About 5 days ago

Follow @ncchurches

Latest Tweets

Dr. Satcher questioned the structures that have upheld health disparities in our communities. By laying the foundation for this work, we can continue taking meaningful action towards promoting a society where we can all thrive. #BlackHistoryMonth @HHSGov @Surgeon_General pic.twitter.com/zrw2…

About 5 days ago

Amen! #MindfulTogether twitter.com/cornerpr…

About 6 days ago

RT @MAHECwnc There has never been a better time to quit smoking and vaping. Protect your health by keeping your lungs healthy! #quitlinenc #covid19 #asheville pic.twitter.com/bKlC…

About 6 days ago

Check out this new resource from @DrugPolicyOrg challenging us to dig deeper and work together to uproot the drug war. uprootingthedrugwar.… #harmreduction #mindfultogether

About 6 days ago

Dr. Julian's work was instrumental to the public health community. We carry his passion as we continue reckoning with our past so that we may continue building the beloved community. Learn more about Dr. Julian's legacy at pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ju…. #BlackHistoryMonth @novapbs pic.twitter.com/JJsm…

Last week

Follow @healthandfaith

Latest Tweets

RT @greenthechurch Be sure to read Green The Church's COO Kim Noble's op ed, "#EnvironmentalJustice in Focus this #BlackHistoryMonth", in the Texas Metro News! @Kimrenay22 #Austin #DFW #Houston #Texas #SanAntonio #EJ ow.ly/mOtw50DGQnN pic.twitter.com/IPOO…

About 5 days ago

RT @ActionAidUSA To build a truly just, equitable & sustainable world, we need to fight for a new #socialcontract. That means: ✔️ Defending democracy ✔️ Fighting for climate justice ✔️ Building equitable food systems ✔️ Supporting women’s leadership. Learn more: bit.ly/2M8xT40 pic.twitter.com/fEWv…

About 5 days ago

RT @interfaithpower IPL is proud to be a signer on this letter. The U.S. must provide bold and socially just leadership to protect our communities from the impacts of climate change, including the threats to our economy- @sbhendershot twitter.com/RealBank…

About 5 days ago

RT @interfaithpower "This is all of our country, this is our mother. It's difficult to not feel obligated to protect this land" - @DebHaalandNM with a powerful reminder of what she believes in. Her passion is exactly what we need right now; the Senate must #ConfirmHaaland! #ConfirmClimate

About 5 days ago

RT @EPA EPA is proud to join our agency partners as we tackle the climate crisis and build a healthier, cleaner, more equitable future for all. Let’s do this! whitehouse.gov/brief…

Last week

Follow @ncipl

Latest Tweets

Copyright © 2021 NC Council of Churches · All Rights Reserved · Website by Tomatillo Design · Hosted by WP Engine