Black Lives Matter.
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

NC Council of Churches

Strength in Unity, Peace through Justice

  • Voices
  • About
    • Overview
    • Staff
    • Members
    • Covenant Partners
    • Issue Statements
    • Governing Board
  • Programs
    • Ecumenical Immigration Alliance
      • Ideas for Action
      • Sign Our Statement
      • The NC Sanctuary Coalition
      • Immigration Bible Study
      • Contact
    • NC Interfaith Power & Light
      • NCIPL Overview
      • Faith in Action NCIPL
      • NCIPL Articles
      • NCIPL Resources
      • Upcoming Events for NCIPL
      • Contact NCIPL
    • Partners in Health & Wholeness
      • PHW Staff
      • Mini-Grants
      • PHW Collaborative Pledge
      • The Overdose Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
      • PHW Articles
      • FAQs
  • Priorities
    • Racial Justice
    • The Overdose Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
    • Gun Violence Prevention
    • Public Education
    • NC Sanctuary Coalition
    • Farmworkers
    • Legislative Advocacy
    • Christian Unity
    • Peace
    • NC No Torture
  • COVID-19 Resources
  • Events
  • Resources
    • Publications & Reports
    • Raleigh Report
    • Lectionary
    • Sermons
  • Donate
  • Council Store
  • Show Search

Search NC Council of Churches

Hide Search

Path to Fairer Maps, Better Government

Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate · September 6, 2019 · Leave a Comment

Click here to sign up to receive the Raleigh Report in your inbox

If politics can be described as a contact sport, it’s perhaps fitting to say that when the Republicans who control North Carolina’s General Assembly went to court to defend the extreme gerrymandering that has helped keep them in power, they suffered no less than an epic beat-down.

Three judges capped years of litigation with an explosive Sept. 3 ruling that scraps the current state House and Senate election district maps and requires them to be redrawn so they treat all voters – even, gasp, Democrats! – fairly and equally under the state constitution.

For those, including the N.C. Council of Churches, who have seen partisan gerrymandering at the root of so many of our state’s governmental challenges, the ruling amounts to a profound reaffirmation of the state courts’ role in remedying abuses by the legislative branch. That reaffirmation becomes even more striking after the U.S. Supreme Court, in a high-profile North Carolina case, decided in June that partisan gerrymandering at any outlandish scale is a problem beyond the federal courts’ reach.

Tellingly, a top Republican legislator, Senate President Pro Tem Phil Berger, said there would be no appeal. Some complaining, for sure – but Berger said it was time to move on, past the redistricting battles that have played out unceasingly for the past decade (and in different contexts, even longer).

Whatever Berger’s rationale, the fact is that in their 357-page ruling, Superior Court Judges Paul Ridgeway of Wake County, Joseph Crosswhite of Iredell and Alma Hinton of Halifax (a Democrat, Republican and Democrat, respectively) left the legislative defendants in the anti-gerrymandering case nowhere to run and nowhere to hide.

The judges, following a 10-day trial in July, synthesized a mountain of evidence showing how the legislative districting scheme deliberately marginalized voters who threatened Republican rule. 

Tracking trial testimony, they laid out in compelling detail how the scheme – engineered by the late Republican mapping guru Tom Hofeller in private consultation with key legislators – went far beyond the sort of partisan gamesmanship that long has accompanied district-drawing conducted as an inherently political process.

And they tied their findings to conclusions flowing directly from several of the state constitution’s bedrock guarantees: Free elections. Equal protection of the laws. Freedom of speech and freedom of assembly.

It was precisely the sort of outcome that U.S. Chief Justice John Roberts Jr. seemed to anticipate when he said remedies for partisan gerrymandering could be found at the state level even if the federal courts were impotent to address it. Some might have thought Roberts was engaged in wishful thinking, but Ridgeway & Co. took him at his word. It’s reasonable to think that if an appeal did reach the state Supreme Court, the justices who form a 6-1 Democratic majority would be on the same wavelength. 

Elections for all

The state constitution, in the course of its Declaration of Rights, states flatly that “All elections shall be free.” There is no elaboration as to what that freedom must entail.

But as the panel of judges asserted, the courts have a basic duty to interpret constitutional language and apply it to real-life situations. They declared that elections aren’t legitimately free if election districts are drawn in such a way that the results are essentially pre-cooked – which is precisely the upshot of extreme partisan gerrymandering.

The lawsuit they considered – brought by the North Carolina branch of Common Cause, along with the state Democratic Party and several individual plaintiffs – challenged a set of House and Senate districts crafted in 2017. But the genesis of the case went back to 2011 – when the legislature carried out its prescribed adjustment of district boundaries to reflect the once-a-decade census taken the previous year.

Republicans had seized control of both legislative houses in the 2010 elections, capitalizing on the tea-party blowback against President Obama and helping execute a national GOP strategy to magnify their state-level influence. Gaining the power to redistrict following the census was a key objective.

The maps they drew, both for legislative and congressional districts, paid off with outsized Republican gains in the elections that followed – outsized compared with the two major parties’ overall vote totals. Even when Democrats accounted for roughly half of the votes cast, Republicans claimed lopsided majorities in the state’s congressional delegation and in both legislative chambers.

The maps were challenged first as being racial gerrymanders – parceling out Democratic-leaning black voters in ways that drained their influence and boosted GOP candidates. Those complaints of unconstitutional race discrimination prompted court orders to redraw.

But the map wizards had other tricks at hand. Using ultra-detailed data from past elections and high-tech mapping software that old-time gerrymanderers could only fantasize about, they fashioned districts where Democratic voters were either packed or cracked.

In the first case, they were so packed together that a Democratic candidate would coast to victory on a tide of surplus votes. In the second, they were cracked, or spread, among a larger number of Republican-leaning districts so they couldn’t reach a critical mass. Net result: A bumper crop of GOP wins.  

A lower-level federal court agreed with Common Cause that a 10-3 Republican split in North Carolina’s congressional delegation – in a so-called purple state where the major parties are competitive – showed partisan gerrymandering that could and should be curbed under the U.S. Constitution. That’s when Chief Justice Roberts and his GOP colleagues disagreed, prevailing in a 5-4 decision. 

But Common Cause and the Democratic Party pressed their challenge to the state legislative maps, even after the 2017 redraw that was supposed to cure the racial gerrymanders.

Republicans since the elections of 2012 had held veto-proof majorities in both the House and Senate, bedeviling first GOP Gov. Pat McCrory and then his successor, Democrat Roy Cooper, while greasing the skids for a narrow-minded, tax-cutting agenda that has worked against the public interest in more ways than we can count.

When the 2018 elections were over – elections featuring a notable “blue wave” — the Republican margin of control had narrowed to 65-55 in the House and 29-21 in the Senate. But this was while the Republicans garnered only 48.8 percent of the two-party House vote and 49.5 percent of the equivalent Senate vote.

Tales of the tape

Judges Ridgeway, Crosswhite and Hinton cited those statistics among many to illustrate how gerrymandered district maps were corrupting a process in which voters should be entitled to an equal say – not only to cast a vote on equal terms, but also to have that vote carry equal weight in deciding the state’s political course.

As the judges aptly put it, extreme partisan gerrymandering – or “redistricting plans that entrench politicians in power, that evince a fundamental distrust of voters by serving the self-interest of political parties over the public good, and that dilute and devalue votes of some citizens compared to others — is contrary to the fundamental right of North Carolina citizens to have elections conducted freely and honestly to ascertain, fairly and truthfully, the will of the people.”

The case took a bizarre turn when computer files developed by the mapping consultant Hofeller wound up in his daughter’s custody after his death in Raleigh last summer. The files were subpoenaed by Common Cause after she told the group of their existence.

Republican defendants sought to keep the material under wraps, but the court allowed some evidence from them to be introduced. And no wonder, because it showed how determined Hofeller had been to maximize Republican prospects at Democrats’ expense. Further, it became clear that the GOP map redraws in 2017 were largely done by Hofeller, in secret, before legislators approved the criteria he was supposed to use.

The judges said they were “troubled” by legislators’ claims denying that such drafts had been prepared. But they cited that history as one reason now to put the legislative mapmakers on a short leash.

The maps will have to be refashioned by Sept. 18 – two weeks after the ruling was issued. Work will have to be done in public, emphasizing transparency, and will have to start with clean slates, not simply building on the “cores” of prior districts. While reasonable efforts may be made to avoid putting incumbents in the same districts, the judges told mapmakers that “partisan considerations and election results data shall not be used” [their emphasis]. 

If the court follows through on its stated resolve to rein in partisan gerrymandering, this could become a watershed in North Carolina’s modern political history.

While it’s true that election outcomes are influenced by many factors – candidate quality, national trends, the preferences of unaffiliated voters, for example – our state’s civic climate has been polluted by redistricting abuses that have enabled legislators once in power to shield themselves from proper accountability.

As practiced by the Republicans who have controlled the General Assembly for the past decade, gerrymandering has posed an obstacle for many – the Council of Churches among them — who think the state’s well-being rests on broader opportunity for all, especially those weighed down by the misfortunes that frustrate dreams of a better life. We now can hope it’s not too much to ask that the court’s powerful ruling becomes a roadmap to fairer, more public-spirited, more compassionate government.

Filed Under: Blog, Homepage Featured, Raleigh Report Tagged With: Civil Discourse, Good Government, N.C. General Assembly

Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate

About Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate

Much goes on in North Carolina's state capital that's important to the Council of Churches. I'm glad to have a chance to help follow the action, transitioning from my career with The News & Observer of Raleigh, where I retired in 2012 as editorial page editor. I'm originally from Virginia but have lived in Cary so long I remember the Kildaire Farm barn.

Read more of my commentary here.

Reader Interactions

More Like This

Raleigh Report: Sidetrack for photo voter ID
Raleigh Report: Flawed deal to resurrect Silent Sam
Time to Take a Knee

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Anonymous comments or comments that target individuals will not be posted (please include your first and last name). All comments must be on topic and respectful. Comments will not be posted until they have been reviewed by a moderator. Comments do not reflect the positions of the NC Council of Churches.

Footer

Contact

NC Council of Churches
27 Horne St.
Raleigh, NC 27607
(919) 828-6501
info@ncchurches.org

Facebook

Partners in Health and Wholeness

Featured

Path to Fairer Maps, Better Government

Latest Tweets

It's a beautiful day in the Triangle. Are you getting ready for that spring weather? 🌿🌺🍀 We are too!! Go to our store and check out our amazing tank tops quoting our motto: "Strength in Unity, Peace through Justice." ncchurches.org/store… pic.twitter.com/oAZr…

About 14 hours ago

TOMORROW! Join us with Rev. Dr. T. Anthony Spearman on Faith Communities Supporting Democracy. There is still time to register. Follow the link >>> ncchurches.org/event… pic.twitter.com/RO2O…

Yesterday

Tomorrow! Make sure to register and join this important conversation on Climate and Health. bit.ly/LancetRSVP twitter.com/The_SEAP…

Yesterday

Action Alert!! The pro-LGBTQ Equality Act has been reintroduced into the new Congress, and the House is poised to vote later this week. Follow the link to sign the petition and tell your representative: Pass the Equality Act now >> act.faithfulamerica.…

About 2 days ago

Join us and @NCIPL this Friday for "The Faithful Work of Environmental Justice." We will discuss the importance of the environmental justice movement in NC, the realities of environmental racism, and more. Follow the link to register! ncchurches.org/event…

About 3 days ago

Follow @ncchurches

Latest Tweets

Dr. Julian's work was instrumental to the public health community. We carry his passion as we continue reckoning with our past so that we may continue building the beloved community. Learn more about Dr. Julian's legacy at pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ju…. #BlackHistoryMonth @novapbs pic.twitter.com/JJsm…

About 11 hours ago

Join Faith in Harm Reduction TODAY at 4 p.m. for the launch of their virtual Roundtable series! The first roundtable centers on the Black church and needs, opportunities, and challenges for harm reduction in that context. Register below: secure.everyaction.c… #MindfulTogether

About 14 hours ago

Do you still need access to health insurance coverage this year? Open enrollment through the health insurance marketplace began on Feb. 15 and ends on May 15. Visit @HealthCareGov to learn more about what this means and how to enroll: healthcare.gov/cover…

About 2 days ago

Pauli Murray's work was rooted in building community that affirms individuals through true equality and justice for all. Learn more about Pauli Murray by visiting the @PauliMurrayCntr Twitter page or website at paulimurraycenter.co…. #BlackHistoryMonth pic.twitter.com/klug…

About 3 days ago

Although Henrietta Lacks' cells revolutionized medical research, their use was done so without her consent. Her story highlights the racial inequities that have and continue to exist in our healthcare systems. Read more here: nature.com/articles/… #BlackHistoryMonth @nature pic.twitter.com/rJAt…

About 6 days ago

Follow @healthandfaith

Latest Tweets

RT @EPA EPA is proud to join our agency partners as we tackle the climate crisis and build a healthier, cleaner, more equitable future for all. Let’s do this! whitehouse.gov/brief…

About a day ago

RT @EPA Proud to be back! @EPA will be there every step of the way, as we tackle the climate crisis, advance climate justice, and create a healthier future for all Americans. twitter.com/WhiteHou…

About a day ago

RT @greenthechurch Tune into Environmental Defense Fund’s Instagram Live on Broadening & Growing the Environmental & Climate Justice Movement in celebration of #BlackHistoryMonth tonight at 6pmEST #EJ #Environmentalist #Environmental #ClimateChange #ClimateJustice #CleanEnergy #ClimateActionNow pic.twitter.com/hBfn…

About a day ago

RT @greenthechurch If you’re passionate about what we do and can bring something unique to the team, get in touch! Email a cover letter, resume, and writing sample(s) to jennifer@greenthechurch.org. pic.twitter.com/CE44…

About a day ago

RT @interfaithpower .@RepDebHaaland: "I can promise you that if I am confirmed as Secretary we will be guided by science." The Senate act quickly to #ConfirmHaaland to ensure @Interior has a leader to fulfill its mission to follow science & protect our #PublicLands for future generations.

About 2 days ago

Follow @ncipl

Latest Tweets

Copyright © 2021 NC Council of Churches · All Rights Reserved · Website by Tomatillo Design · Hosted by WP Engine