Registration is now open for our 2019 Legislative Seminar
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to footer

NC Council of Churches

Strength in Unity, Peace through Justice

  • Voices
  • About
  • Programs
    • Ecumenical Immigration Alliance
      • Ideas for Action
      • Sign Our Statements
      • The NC Sanctuary Coalition
      • Immigration Bible Study
      • Contact
    • NC Interfaith Power & Light
      • NCIPL Overview
      • Faith in Action NCIPL
      • NCIPL Articles
      • NCIPL Resources
      • Upcoming Events for NCIPL
      • Contact NCIPL
    • Partners in Health & Wholeness
      • PHW Staff
      • Mini-Grants
      • PHW Collaborative
      • The Opioid Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
      • PHW Articles
      • FAQs
  • Priorities
    • Christian Unity
    • Gun Violence Prevention
    • Farmworkers
    • Interfaith Collaboration
    • Legislative Advocacy
    • NC No Torture
    • NC Sanctuary Coalition
    • Peace
    • Public Education
  • Events
  • Resources
    • Publications & Reports
    • Raleigh Report
    • Lectionary
    • Sermons
    • Newsletter Archive
  • Donate
  • Show Search

Search NC Council of Churches

Subscribe to Updates from the NC Council of Churches








Weekly E-news:
Raleigh Report:
Faith and Immigration Newsletter:
Health and Faith Perspective:
NC Interfaith Power & Light:

Hide Search

Voter ID Follows Budget Bulldozer

Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate · June 11, 2018 · Leave a Comment

Click here to sign up to receive the Raleigh Report in your inbox

North Carolina’s new state budget – now on a fast track to final enactment by the Republican-controlled General Assembly over Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper’s veto – represents a miserable failure in open, accountable legislating.

Apparently for the first time on record, a budget bill was forced through the state Senate and House via a process that didn’t allow any amendments even to be considered.

Yes, it’s true that this budget, for the fiscal year beginning July 1, was approved in tentative form a year ago as part of the legislature’s two-year budgeting cycle.

But the normal process wisely allows for tweaks before the cycle’s second year kicks in. This year, any such changes were made behind closed doors by budget-wranglers who answered to the Republican chiefs in their respective chambers – Senate President Pro Tem Phil Berger of Eden and Speaker of the House Tim Moore of Kings Mountain.

What emerged was a bill that notably responded to public pressure for higher teacher salaries. Yet legislators aligned with Cooper – who has called for even bigger teacher pay hikes and who has identified a perfectly reasonable way to pay for them – weren’t allowed to try to shape the bill in that fashion.

Debating proposed amendments was too inconvenient when Berger, Moore & Co. already knew exactly what they wanted to do.

And it was potentially too embarrassing for Republicans who would have been under orders to vote against a teacher pay plan preferred by public school advocates and teachers but advanced by Democrats.

Marching orders

Might Democratic legislators have offered amendments and forced votes in an effort to score political points, even if they were almost guaranteed to lose? Sure.

But that’s the sort of thing that happens when policies are set in the course of open debate, with competing views being aired and with legislators taking responsibility for their positions as amendments and bills are voted up or down. In other words, it’s the sort of thing that happens when a system operates as a democracy, not merely as a tool to impose the agenda of those in power.

Republican chiefs decided on their own what the new budget’s final version would look like and how it would be handled. They wound up stumbling even farther down their ill-chosen policy path of tax relief mainly benefiting those on whom fortune has already smiled.

They also short-circuited the deliberative process in a way that serves their own political ends: The sooner this legislative session is over and done with, the sooner they and their troops can get out on the campaign trail in advance of what are shaping up as unusually competitive fall elections.

The Senate, by a party line tally of 34-13, overrode Cooper’s budget veto on June 7 and the House is set to follow suit on June 12. Once the budget is in place, another politically self-serving GOP initiative is likely to draw the spotlight: a proposed amendment to the state constitution, put forward with a strong push from Speaker Moore, requiring voters to show a photo ID before casting an in-person ballot. House Bill 1092, introduced on June 7, would set a statewide referendum on the amendment during the elections in November.

Tellingly, no specifics as to how the ID requirement would work are included in the bill; a follow-up law would have to be passed. Whether such a law would get over the federal constitutional bar likely depends on how strictly it limited the kinds of acceptable identification. What top Republicans may well hope is that a referendum on voter ID would boost friendly turn-out during an election when many voters are likely to be motivated by disgust with a reckless, ethically challenged president, putting Republican candidates at risk.

Costly lessons

On the surface, the $23.9 billion budget for 2018-19 looks to be a steady-as-it-goes sort of spending plan, with modest increases in several areas. The state employee workforce, which came under predictable strain as wages stagnated during the post-2008 recession, will receive raises of at least 2 percent. Teachers’ pay hikes will average 6.5 percent, although classroom veterans won’t fare as well as their junior colleagues. Their experience still isn’t properly valued.

Cooper had called for teacher pay to go up by an average of 8 percent, and when he spoke to thousands of teachers who rallied outside the Legislative Building on May 16, he connected with this politically potent group. Their bond again was evident when teachers joined him on June 6 for his veto announcement.

“When you are continuing to drop in per-pupil expenditures, when you’re still 37th in the country in teacher pay, that’s unacceptable,” the governor declared. His formal veto statement was short and stinging: “I will not sign my name to a budget that protects corporations and the wealthy at the expense of schools and students. This budget falls short of what our teachers and public education need. North Carolinians will not stand for a secret, unchangeable budget born of a broken legislative process.”

Cooper had targeted the legislature’s decision to continue with cuts in personal and corporate income taxes, despite previous cuts that are costing the state an estimated $2.6 billion a year compared with the revenue that otherwise would have been collected. The annual cost of further cuts slated to take effect in 2019 is pegged at $900 million.

His idea was to suspend the planned reduction in the corporate tax from 3 percent to 2.5 percent while keeping the personal income tax at 5.499 percent for earnings above $200,000. That would have funded his proposed teacher pay raises and addressed some other priorities, especially in environmental protection — an area ravaged by legislative budget-cutting that has gone hand in hand with the reckless loosening of regulations.

Troubling tactic

Moore ripped Cooper’s veto, saying the governor “has once again shown that he is more concerned about scoring political points than helping North Carolinians.” What the speaker and his allies aren’t eager to acknowledge is that despite the new budget’s various spending increases, the entire budget has endured what amounts to a hollowing out under tax-cut pressure.

Even if there’s an election-year effort to mask the damage, the state has fallen behind on a range of public investments that help give people fair access to opportunity – investments in education, health care, transportation, the justice system, uplift for struggling rural counties. Those are the kinds of policy choices that again will hang in the balance when voters go to the polls this fall.

If voter ID also is on the ballot, the chemistry of the election could be altered – and from the standpoint of social justice advocates including the N.C. Council of Churches, not altered in a good way. A voter ID requirement is popular, and it’s possible to imagine such a rule that would not be unduly burdensome to citizens who lack a driver’s license or other standard type of government-issued identification.

But the Republican legislators who tried, starting in 2013, to enforce such a rule weren’t so much interested in preventing voter fraud – their cover story, despite no evidence that such fraud is a significant problem – as they were in eroding the number of Democratic-leaning voters. They bundled a strict ID requirement with other measures that a federal appeals court memorably, and damningly, said targeted African-American voters “with almost surgical precision.”

Groups such as the League of Women Voters will push back against voter ID if the referendum goes forward. Already they make a strong case. Yet in the absence of a law spelling out how the rule would work, opponents will have to argue against an abstract requirement that strikes many people as reasonable enough. And they’ll have to go to bat for minority voting rights – no doubt with demagogues claiming that what ID opponents really want is permission to cheat.

Voter ID from the start has been advanced in bad faith. Cheating of the sort that an ID rule would prevent is practically non-existent. And the legislature’s Republican majorities have been eager to warp the state’s election rules in their favor – warp them so badly that federal judges have told them to stop. This fall, if a referendum battle unfolds amidst attempts by Republican legislators to hold power, justice advocates will want to keep that sorry history in mind.

Filed Under: Blog, Raleigh Report Tagged With: N.C. General Assembly, Public Education, State Budget

Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate

About Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate

Much goes on in North Carolina's state capital that's important to the Council of Churches. I'm glad to have a chance to help follow the action, transitioning from my career with The News & Observer of Raleigh, where I retired in 2012 as editorial page editor. I'm originally from Virginia but have lived in Cary so long I remember the Kildaire Farm barn.

Read more of my commentary here.

Reader Interactions

More Like This

Pushback Path Leads to Court
Power Struggle has them Scrambling
Improving the State of North Carolina

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Anonymous comments or comments that target individuals will not be posted (please include your first and last name). All comments must be on topic and respectful. Comments will not be posted until they have been reviewed by a moderator. Comments do not reflect the positions of the NC Council of Churches.

Footer

Contact

NC Council of Churches
27 Horne St.
Raleigh, NC 27607
(919) 828-6501
info@ncchurches.org

Featured Resource

From the Lectionary
Celebrating Abrahamic Faiths
March 10, 2019 · 2 Corinthiaans 5:16-21

Latest Tweets

Rob Schofield of @NCPolicyWatch will be leading a workshop at our entitled Power Struggles, the Sequel. He'll review legislative efforts to curb the governor’s powers. Are those efforts continuing, and what do they involve? More info: ncchurches.org/2019s… #ncpol @ncjustice pic.twitter.com/HvNg…

About 2 days ago

Excited to have The Rev. Ron Stief, executive director of @NRCATtweets join us on March 9 to discuss strategies for ending CIA torture. Lunch and childcare are free if you register by March 6. More info: ncchurches.org/event… #ncpol pic.twitter.com/8JYm…

About 2 days ago

There is still time to join us in Charlotte on March 12 and 13 for the Come to the Table Conference. The deadline to register has been extended to February 25. Many of our Council staff will be presenting workshops so we hope to see you there! rafiusa.org/cttt/201… pic.twitter.com/kDzF…

About 5 days ago

RT @healthandfaith Join us NEXT TUESDAY, February 27, for Medicaid Expansion Advocacy Day. We'll join together with fellow North Carolinians to tell our lawmakers it's time to #CloseTheGapNC Register today: docs.google.com/form… @nchealthaccess pic.twitter.com/7D5D…

About 5 days ago

Excited to have The Rev. Ron Steif, executive director of @NRCATtweets join us in just a couple of weeks (March 9). He'll share with us ways the faith community can help bring an end to CIA torture. Space is limited so register today! ncchurches.org/event… pic.twitter.com/uapr…

About 5 days ago

Follow @ncchurches

Latest Tweets

What an awesome program! Thanks @CISChatham for teaching our youth how to eat healthy on a budget. #health #nc twitter.com/CISChath…

About 2 days ago

Our PHW Collaborative Application is now live! Read more at the link about how your faith community can partner with us to promote health & wholeness in NC. #health #faith #NC ncchurches.org/progr… pic.twitter.com/Fr83…

About 3 days ago

Now more than ever we must show our support for Medicaid expansion. Check out our Advocacy Toolkit on writing an op-ed to your local paper to make your voice heard! #CloseTheGapNC #ncga #ncpol #health #faith ncchurches.org/take-…

About 4 days ago

Our apologies: *Wednesday* Feb. 27! twitter.com/healthan…

About 4 days ago

Join us NEXT TUESDAY, February 27, for Medicaid Expansion Advocacy Day. We'll join together with fellow North Carolinians to tell our lawmakers it's time to #CloseTheGapNC Register today: docs.google.com/form… @nchealthaccess pic.twitter.com/7D5D…

About 5 days ago

Follow @healthandfaith

Latest Tweets

RT @CareBoutClimate About to start the Building Grassroots Power meeting for @uscan! #buildinggrassrootspower @AnthropoceneAL @SustainingWay @NCIPL @peoplesjusticec @GeorgiaWAND pic.twitter.com/QgEl…

About 10 hours ago

RT @UNCCE3 CE3 Director Jonas Monast is speaking in Fort Worth, Texas, at @TAMULawSchool's Energy Law Symposium on tomorrow's panel, "Between Markets and Regulation –Electricity Governance in Transition." law.tamu.edu/faculty… pic.twitter.com/RkcJ…

About 2 days ago

RT @NCCoastalFed Three #OBX local govt officials to ⁦@SenThomTillis - protect our coast and our economy & oppose #offshore #oil drilling in #NC #ncpol #ncga ⁦@ThomTillis⁩ newsobserver.com/opi…

About 2 days ago

RT @Michael_S_Regan “People affected by GenX & PFAS pollution in the Cape Fear River deserve real relief, and this order provides that relief ... We listened to the comments from the community, leaders, public utilities & established a strong path forward to protect #waterquality & public health.” twitter.com/wectnews…

About 2 days ago

RT @ncchurches There is still time to join us in Charlotte on March 12 and 13 for the Come to the Table Conference. The deadline to register has been extended to February 25. Many of our Council staff will be presenting workshops so we hope to see you there! rafiusa.org/cttt/201… pic.twitter.com/kDzF…

About 3 days ago

Follow @ncipl

Latest Tweets

No matter what type of barrier, border communities are opposed! We need to #RevitalizeNotMilitarize our border region. Congress—do not give Trump any more money for ICE, CBP, or a border wall! CALL to #DefundHate: (202) 224-3121 pic.twitter.com/xBVM…

About 2 months ago

Let's @SupportFLOC in the upcoming #BoycottVUSE against Reynolds American Inc. and defend our tobacco farmworkers so that they may have a voice to negotiate better working conditions without fear of retaliation! floc.com/wordpress/b…

Last year

.@POTUS @realDonaldTrump Keep America welcoming. Refugee resettlement is a proud American legacy with bipartisan support #RefugeesWelcome

About 2 years ago

.@realDonaldTrump & @POTUS Christians oppose policies that would deny Muslims refuge and preference Christians: bit.ly/FaithLeaders4…

About 2 years ago

.@realDonaldTrump & @POTUS People of faith OPPOSE a religious litmus test for refugees bit.ly/FaithLeaders4… #RefugeesWelcome

About 2 years ago

Follow @NCRCJI

Copyright © 2019 NC Council of Churches · All Rights Reserved · Website by Tomatillo Design · Hosted by WP Engine