Black Lives Matter.
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

NC Council of Churches

Strength in Unity, Peace through Justice

  • Voices
  • About
    • Overview
    • Staff
    • Members
    • Covenant Partners
    • Issue Statements
    • Governing Board
  • Programs
    • Ecumenical Immigration Alliance
      • Ideas for Action
      • Sign Our Statement
      • The NC Sanctuary Coalition
      • Immigration Bible Study
      • Contact
    • NC Interfaith Power & Light
      • NCIPL Overview
      • Faith in Action NCIPL
      • NCIPL Articles
      • NCIPL Resources
      • Upcoming Events for NCIPL
      • Contact NCIPL
    • Partners in Health & Wholeness
      • PHW Staff
      • Mini-Grants
      • PHW Collaborative Pledge
      • The Overdose Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
      • PHW Articles
      • FAQs
  • Priorities
    • Racial Justice
    • The Overdose Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
    • Gun Violence Prevention
    • Public Education
    • NC Sanctuary Coalition
    • Farmworkers
    • Legislative Advocacy
    • Christian Unity
    • Peace
    • NC No Torture
  • COVID-19 Resources
  • Events
  • Resources
    • Publications & Reports
    • Raleigh Report
    • Lectionary
    • Sermons
  • Donate
  • Council Store
  • Show Search

Search NC Council of Churches

Hide Search

H.B. 2 ‘Compromise’ Must Protect Rights

Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate · March 3, 2017 · Leave a Comment

Click here to sign up to receive the Raleigh Report in your inbox

The fight over North Carolina’s House Bill 2 – the law that notoriously stamps the state’s seal of approval on discrimination against lesbian, gay and transgender folks – has devolved into a form of trench warfare.

Republican legislators and social conservatives who support the law remain dug in against an outright repeal. They can’t afford to admit they made a gross misjudgment when, a year ago, they rushed the bill through without heed to the economic and ethical consequences.

Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper and his allies among LGBT and civil rights advocates are just as dug in with their insistence that the law’s sponsors take responsibility for cleaning up the mess they created. They’re willing to negotiate the terms of repeal, but not to concede that H.B. 2 ever has served a valid purpose or that the discrimination it codifies should be sustained.

The political stakes are huge and the risk of casualties is high. Just ask Pat McCrory, who likely would be serving his second term as governor if his fellow Republicans in the General Assembly hadn’t left him holding the bag as H.B. 2’s most visible defender.

After Cooper’s victory over McCrory in November, the governor-elect tried to broker a deal that would have wiped H.B. 2 off the books. He convinced the Charlotte City Council to repeal its ordinance allowing transgender people to use restrooms in public facilities matching their gender identity. H.B. 2 had been promoted as a way to nullify that ordinance, although the bill was even more intrusive and objectionable.

Charlotte’s about-face was supposed to trigger repeal of the state law during a special legislative session in December. But Republican chiefs in the House and Senate couldn’t round up enough votes in their party caucuses, where anti-LGBT currents run deep, for an outright repeal, and they didn’t want to end up letting the Democrats boast that they’d made the repeal happen.

Democrats, for their part, refused to go along with a Republican-backed bill that was touted as a repeal but that left key H.B. 2 provisions temporarily intact.

Out came the entrenching tools, the barbed wire and the rhetorical machine guns.

Looming deadline

Once the legislature convened in late January for its 2017 session, the pattern was set. H.B. 2 opponents hammered away at the need for repeal, citing not only the human rights issues involved but also the economic losses from tournaments, concerts and corporate investments cancelled in protest.

Defenders stuck to their absurd story that the law was essential to keep sex offenders from preying on women and girls in public restrooms and locker rooms. They glossed over the law’s lack of enforcement mechanisms and the fact that the kinds of misbehavior they claimed to be so worried about, if they ever occurred, were already illegal.

Every day, it seems, has brought another press conference full of finger-pointing and blame-storming. Republicans have kept floating bills they’ve tried to depict as versions of repeal, without purging the modes of discrimination that make H.B. 2 so toxic. Cooper and his allies don’t want to accept a “compromise” that could let the GOP salvage a victory and sell vulnerable folks down the river.

All the while, the NCAA has ratcheted up the pressure for repeal with warnings that North Carolina could lose hosting privileges for up to six years of collegiate sports tournaments. No North Carolina politician with enough sense to come in out of the rain wants to be tagged with responsibility for losing those popular and economically significant events.

With the NCAA brandishing a deadline, desperate legislators have tried to find a formula that would allow the state to back away from the H.B. 2 precipice. Any such formula will need bipartisan support to succeed. But so far, true consensus has been a mirage.

Solution search

Cooper has backed House Bill 107, which would combine repeal with a toughening of penalties for sex-related crimes committed in restrooms and other such facilities. It also would require a month’s notice before a local government could enact anti-discrimination measures that go beyond those in state law. It’s a reasonable approach, but we shouldn’t hold our breath waiting for Republican legislative leaders to bring it to a vote.

Now comes House Bill 186, with two Republicans and two Democrats listed as primary sponsors. It backs away from a few of H.B. 2’s more onerous features. But not by much.

For example, cities wouldn’t be allowed to regulate access to restrooms unless they owned the building. So a transgender person in a movie theater, for example, still could not use a restroom designated for people of his or her gender.

That would have the effect of forcing someone who looked, acted and thought of herself as a woman – even after having been born male – to use the men’s room. And vice versa. This addresses a non-existent problem by setting up situations guaranteed to freak everyone out.

The bill also would expand the categories of people against whom it is illegal to discriminate, but discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity would not be covered. That fails to correct what is perhaps H.B. 2’s central flaw, by which local governments are barred from extending such protections and the state refuses to do so.

Here’s H.B. 186’s kicker, adding insult to injury: If a city decided to enlarge the scope of its anti-discrimination code, its new ordinance could be put on the ballot for a referendum. Such a popular vote on a controversial ordinance could be a worthwhile check on a city council; Raleigh and Asheville are among the municipalities that allow for such a step.

People power?

The crucial difference is how hard, or how easy, it is to force a referendum. In Raleigh, for example, opponents of an ordinance now must collect signatures from voters numbering at least 10 percent of those registered for the last election. The News & Observer of Raleigh pegged that at about 30,000 signatures.

Under H.B. 186, by contrast, a referendum petition would succeed if backers gathered signatures from at least 10 percent of the number of people who voted in the last municipal election, when turnouts tend to be low. The N&O calculated that, based on turnout in the 2015 Raleigh city elections, only 3,600 signatures would be needed to challenge expanded anti-discrimination rules. Given the hullabaloo such a move by the City Council likely would generate, picking up 3,600 signatures sounds like something that could done over a weekend.

That doesn’t mean referendum voters necessarily would block such an ordinance. Raleigh, for instance, is a pretty tolerant place.

But Cooper was on the mark when he criticized any move that in essence would put some people’s civil rights up to a popular vote. Almost by definition, that’s an invitation to tyranny of the majority, when the well-being of a minority – perhaps an unpopular minority in some areas – is placed at the majority’s mercy. Our laws should instead be their shield from repression.

The Council of Churches has opposed H.B. 2 from the get-go as an unnecessary and cruel indulgence in anti-LGBT demagoguery. The law attempted to fix something that wasn’t broken and in the process did enormous damage to North Carolina’s reputation besides treating lesbians, gays and transgender people like dirt.

Any truce between the two sides in the H.B. 2 struggle probably will have to entail compromises by each. But no truce will be acceptable if the rights of some of our neighbors – people who just want and deserve to be treated as equal before the law – are sacrificed. Economic concerns, as serious as they are, can’t be allowed to trample that basic principle.

Filed Under: Blog, Homepage Featured, Raleigh Report Tagged With: Economic Justice, Good Government, Human Rights, LGBTQ, N.C. General Assembly

Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate

About Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate

Much goes on in North Carolina's state capital that's important to the Council of Churches. I'm glad to have a chance to help follow the action, transitioning from my career with The News & Observer of Raleigh, where I retired in 2012 as editorial page editor. I'm originally from Virginia but have lived in Cary so long I remember the Kildaire Farm barn.

Read more of my commentary here.

Reader Interactions

More Like This

Raise the Wage
Raleigh Report – April 29, 2019
Raleigh Report – April 22, 2019

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Anonymous comments or comments that target individuals will not be posted (please include your first and last name). All comments must be on topic and respectful. Comments will not be posted until they have been reviewed by a moderator. Comments do not reflect the positions of the NC Council of Churches.

Footer

Contact

NC Council of Churches
27 Horne St.
Raleigh, NC 27607
(919) 828-6501
info@ncchurches.org

Facebook

Partners in Health and Wholeness

Featured

H.B. 2 ‘Compromise’ Must Protect Rights

Latest Tweets

Just last week, our Governing Board adopted a resolution calling for the removal of Confederate symbols in public squares. As people of faith & conscience, we believe such monuments are a constant reminder of prejudice against black and brown people. >> ncchurches.org/2021/… pic.twitter.com/iGCX…

About 2 days ago

"Amanda Gorman in her inauguration poem 'The Hill We Climb' begins with the lines: 'When day comes we ask ourselves where can we find light in this never-ending shade?'" Read more of this 2nd Sunday lenten reflection from Elizabeth Brewington >> ncchurches.org/2021/… pic.twitter.com/pgge…

About 2 days ago

"Perhaps it’s the pandemic that offers a fitting analogy to the condition of our politics as Americans try to recover from the trauma of Jan. 6 – when we came dangerously close to the onset of an anti-democratic Trump-ocracy." Read more from Steve Ford >> ncchurches.org/2021/…

About 3 days ago

FACT: Countries where maternal mortality rates have significantly dropped (~ -50%) in the past few decades (e.g., France, Germany, Sweden), have generous paid leave laws. #BlackHistoryMonth #Paidleave #BlackHealth pic.twitter.com/PgWW…

About 3 days ago

Call your Member of Congress and tell them paid leave is crucial to public health and economic recovery. Text paidleave (one word) to 844-955-2880 or visit bit.ly/39PWQde to begin. #AmericanRescuePlan #PaidLeave #BlackHealth

About 4 days ago

Follow @ncchurches

Latest Tweets

Dr. Satcher questioned the structures that have upheld health disparities in our communities. By laying the foundation for this work, we can continue taking meaningful action towards promoting a society where we can all thrive. #BlackHistoryMonth @HHSGov @Surgeon_General pic.twitter.com/zrw2…

About 3 days ago

Amen! #MindfulTogether twitter.com/cornerpr…

About 3 days ago

RT @MAHECwnc There has never been a better time to quit smoking and vaping. Protect your health by keeping your lungs healthy! #quitlinenc #covid19 #asheville pic.twitter.com/bKlC…

About 3 days ago

Check out this new resource from @DrugPolicyOrg challenging us to dig deeper and work together to uproot the drug war. uprootingthedrugwar.… #harmreduction #mindfultogether

About 3 days ago

Dr. Julian's work was instrumental to the public health community. We carry his passion as we continue reckoning with our past so that we may continue building the beloved community. Learn more about Dr. Julian's legacy at pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ju…. #BlackHistoryMonth @novapbs pic.twitter.com/JJsm…

About 4 days ago

Follow @healthandfaith

Latest Tweets

RT @greenthechurch Be sure to read Green The Church's COO Kim Noble's op ed, "#EnvironmentalJustice in Focus this #BlackHistoryMonth", in the Texas Metro News! @Kimrenay22 #Austin #DFW #Houston #Texas #SanAntonio #EJ ow.ly/mOtw50DGQnN pic.twitter.com/IPOO…

About 3 days ago

RT @ActionAidUSA To build a truly just, equitable & sustainable world, we need to fight for a new #socialcontract. That means: ✔️ Defending democracy ✔️ Fighting for climate justice ✔️ Building equitable food systems ✔️ Supporting women’s leadership. Learn more: bit.ly/2M8xT40 pic.twitter.com/fEWv…

About 3 days ago

RT @interfaithpower IPL is proud to be a signer on this letter. The U.S. must provide bold and socially just leadership to protect our communities from the impacts of climate change, including the threats to our economy- @sbhendershot twitter.com/RealBank…

About 3 days ago

RT @interfaithpower "This is all of our country, this is our mother. It's difficult to not feel obligated to protect this land" - @DebHaalandNM with a powerful reminder of what she believes in. Her passion is exactly what we need right now; the Senate must #ConfirmHaaland! #ConfirmClimate

About 3 days ago

RT @EPA EPA is proud to join our agency partners as we tackle the climate crisis and build a healthier, cleaner, more equitable future for all. Let’s do this! whitehouse.gov/brief…

About 5 days ago

Follow @ncipl

Latest Tweets

Copyright © 2021 NC Council of Churches · All Rights Reserved · Website by Tomatillo Design · Hosted by WP Engine