Black Lives Matter.
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

NC Council of Churches

Strength in Unity, Peace through Justice

  • Voices
  • About
    • Overview
    • Staff
    • Members
    • Covenant Partners
    • Issue Statements
    • Governing Board
  • Programs
    • Ecumenical Immigration Alliance
      • Ideas for Action
      • Sign Our Statement
      • The NC Sanctuary Coalition
      • Immigration Bible Study
      • Contact
    • NC Interfaith Power & Light
      • NCIPL Overview
      • Faith in Action NCIPL
      • NCIPL Articles
      • NCIPL Resources
      • Upcoming Events for NCIPL
      • Contact NCIPL
    • Partners in Health & Wholeness
      • PHW Staff
      • Mini-Grants
      • PHW Collaborative Pledge
      • The Overdose Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
      • PHW Articles
      • FAQs
  • Priorities
    • Racial Justice
    • The Overdose Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
    • Gun Violence Prevention
    • Public Education
    • NC Sanctuary Coalition
    • Farmworkers
    • Legislative Advocacy
    • Christian Unity
    • Peace
    • NC No Torture
  • COVID-19 Resources
  • Events
  • Resources
    • Publications & Reports
    • Raleigh Report
    • Lectionary
    • Sermons
  • Donate
  • Council Store
  • Show Search

Search NC Council of Churches

Hide Search

When Lawmakers Itch to Execute

Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate · May 7, 2015 · Leave a Comment

Click here to sign up to receive the Raleigh Report in your inbox

The last person to be put to death by the State of North Carolina – in other words, put to death on behalf of all of us who live here and choose the leaders who write our laws – was Samuel Flippen, 36, who was given a lethal injection at Central Prison in Raleigh at 2 a.m. on Friday, Aug. 18, 2006 as his parents watched.

The execution was the final chapter in a sad tale – of that there’s no doubt. Flippen had been convicted in the courts of Forsyth County on charges of murdering his two-year-old stepdaughter, Britnie Hutton, in 1994. The little girl died en route to a hospital after Flippen summoned rescue workers, saying she had fallen over in her high chair. An autopsy disclosed injuries indicating that she’d been beaten.

Prosecutors successfully argued that the assault rose to the level of first-degree murder, involving premeditation and deliberation. A jury found Flippen guilty and recommended the death sentence. That sentence was vacated by the state Supreme Court because the jury had not properly weighed Flippen’s lack of a criminal record as a mitigating factor. But a second jury recommended the same sentence and this time it held.

Flippen never acknowledged responsibility for the death. But even if he had struck the child as the evidence tended to show, a reasonable argument could be made that the crime should have been treated as second-degree murder, which would have spared him from death row. In fact, the state had offered to let him plea to the lesser charge.

The case thus typified some of the worst aspects of a system that uses death as the ultimate punishment. If Sammy Flippen hit a little girl so hard that it killed her, he deserved a tough punishment indeed. But what if his lawyer had convinced him to take that plea bargain? Even stipulating that Flippen was a murderer, his eventual fate seems to have hinged on bad legal strategy and bad luck as much as any rational finding that his crime warranted execution.

Mounting doubts

In the years since 2006, public support for the death penalty has eroded. That reflects a growing unease with a penalty that’s not only arbitrary but also irreversible – while the headlines time and again have told of men released from death row because their convictions were tainted by prosecutorial misconduct or errors of law, or because they were shown to be innocent. It reflects the efforts by groups such as People of Faith Against the Death Penalty, originally a project of the NC Council of Churches, to highlight the inequities and ethical dilemmas posed by state-sanctioned killing.

Specific roadblocks also factor into North Carolina’s unofficial death penalty moratorium. Physicians have become reluctant to cooperate with the statutory rule that one of them be on hand to monitor lethal injections – a rule that essentially puts them in the position of helping to take a life.

Meanwhile, nationwide concerns about the injection process – with lawsuits alleging the possibility of unnecessary suffering in violation of the constitutional ban on punishments that are cruel and unusual – have resulted in an overall shortage of the drugs typically used.  Manufacturers are queasy about having their products, intended for health care, used in death chambers.

With 149 people still facing death sentences here, death penalty advocates in the General Assembly are impatient with the delay. But legislation that cleared the state House on April 29 would represent a big step backward, not only in helping to restart executions but also in making the process even more objectionable from the standpoint of inmates’ rights and accountability to the public.

House Bill 774, sponsored by veteran Republican Rep. Leo Daughtry of Smithfield, would do away with the requirement that physicians monitor the administration of the lethal drugs. That role instead could be filled by a licensed physician assistant, nurse practitioner, registered nurse, emergency medical technician or paramedic.

Of course, the “monitoring” job could turn more complicated if, as has occurred in other states, the execution went awry because of a failure to properly insert I.V. lines, failure to inject a proper dose or another such mishap. Then the monitor would have to draw on his or her expertise either to continue the procedure, without in effect torturing the inmate, or to call it off. There’s a potential for a ghoulish travesty.

That potential rises because of another feature in the bill. No longer would the lethal formula be prescribed by law (“an ultrashort-acting barbiturate in combination with a chemical paralytic agent”). Instead, the state could choose to inject any “substance or substances in a lethal quantity sufficient to cause death…” so long as the procedure met constitutional standards.

Presumably a shot of rat poison wouldn’t qualify. But the bill would shield any identifying information about the source of the drugs. That would make it hard to reach an independent evaluation of the drugs’ effects and whether they involved the infliction of pain.

A Democratic-sponsored amendment to the bill (in fact a total rewrite) would have abolished the state’s death penalty and converted death sentences to life in prison without possibility of parole – on balance, a far better way to punish those who commit even the worst kinds of murders. But the amendment was withdrawn before it could be voted down.

Meanwhile, an amendment by Democratic Rep. Gale Adcock of Cary, a nurse practitioner who is the chief health officer at software giant SAS, would have taken nurses and physician assistants off the list of medical professionals who could be death chamber monitors. That would put them on the same ethical footing as doctors, and appropriately so. The amendment failed by a vote of 35-81 before the bill was approved 84-33.

How much pain?

By rueful coincidence, on the same day that HB 774 was being debated and passed, the U.S. Supreme Court was hearing oral arguments in a lawsuit involving the mechanics of lethal injections.

Three prisoners on death row in Oklahoma want the court to block the use of a sedative called midazolam, which is supposed to render an inmate unconscious before drugs that stop his heart take effect.

The complaint is that midazolam can’t be relied upon to block the pain when those killing drugs kick in. That seems to have been the case during three executions last year. Midazolam is used because the traditional death chamber sedative thiopental (a short-acting barbiturate of the kind North Carolina still requires) has become hard to obtain.

Justice Elena Kagan likened what could happen to an inadequately sedated inmate as being “burned alive from the inside.” But her conservative colleagues weren’t impressed. In comments from the bench, their impatience with death penalty critics boiled over.

“Let’s be honest about what’s going on here,” said Justice Samuel Alito Jr. “Executions can be carried out painlessly.” Maybe they can be, but will they? And Alito wondered, “Is it appropriate for the judiciary to countenance what amounts to a guerrilla war against the death penalty?”

That sounds like the frustrated cry of a judge who’d rather not have to wrestle with whether an execution method does in fact pose the risk of cruel and unusual punishment. But inmates and their lawyers who raise that possibility, thus delaying the death chamber parade, are simply asking that their constitutional rights be given due regard. If executions can’t take place without violating those rights, then let the executions lapse.

Might North Carolina authorities want to use midazolam in a death penalty revival? Daughtry’s bill would make it hard to find out. Look to the conservative Senate now to give the bill a smooth ride, foisting the issue on Republican Gov. Pat McCrory.

Perhaps it’s difficult to work up much sympathy for inmates who are in the fix they’re in because they killed someone, probably not worrying about the pain. But we shouldn’t follow Alito in chastising those who insist that even our worst criminals be treated in accord with constitutional standards of decency. If the death penalty collapses in North Carolina under the weight of legal challenges and shifting public opinion, as it has in several other states in recent years, that will amount to real progress toward a larger form of justice.

Filed Under: Blog, Homepage Featured, Raleigh Report Tagged With: Death Penalty, Good Government, N.C. General Assembly, Religion & Society

Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate

About Steve Ford, Volunteer Program Associate

Much goes on in North Carolina's state capital that's important to the Council of Churches. I'm glad to have a chance to help follow the action, transitioning from my career with The News & Observer of Raleigh, where I retired in 2012 as editorial page editor. I'm originally from Virginia but have lived in Cary so long I remember the Kildaire Farm barn.

Read more of my commentary here.

Reader Interactions

More Like This

Raleigh Report — April 17, 2017
GOP Mantra: Party Hearty!
Big Stakes in High Court Pick

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Anonymous comments or comments that target individuals will not be posted (please include your first and last name). All comments must be on topic and respectful. Comments will not be posted until they have been reviewed by a moderator. Comments do not reflect the positions of the NC Council of Churches.

Footer

Contact

NC Council of Churches
27 Horne St.
Raleigh, NC 27607
(919) 828-6501
info@ncchurches.org

Facebook

Partners in Health and Wholeness

Featured

When Lawmakers Itch to Execute

Latest Tweets

Just last week, our Governing Board adopted a resolution calling for the removal of Confederate symbols in public squares. As people of faith & conscience, we believe such monuments are a constant reminder of prejudice against black and brown people. >> ncchurches.org/2021/… pic.twitter.com/iGCX…

About 2 days ago

"Amanda Gorman in her inauguration poem 'The Hill We Climb' begins with the lines: 'When day comes we ask ourselves where can we find light in this never-ending shade?'" Read more of this 2nd Sunday lenten reflection from Elizabeth Brewington >> ncchurches.org/2021/… pic.twitter.com/pgge…

About 2 days ago

"Perhaps it’s the pandemic that offers a fitting analogy to the condition of our politics as Americans try to recover from the trauma of Jan. 6 – when we came dangerously close to the onset of an anti-democratic Trump-ocracy." Read more from Steve Ford >> ncchurches.org/2021/…

About 2 days ago

FACT: Countries where maternal mortality rates have significantly dropped (~ -50%) in the past few decades (e.g., France, Germany, Sweden), have generous paid leave laws. #BlackHistoryMonth #Paidleave #BlackHealth pic.twitter.com/PgWW…

About 3 days ago

Call your Member of Congress and tell them paid leave is crucial to public health and economic recovery. Text paidleave (one word) to 844-955-2880 or visit bit.ly/39PWQde to begin. #AmericanRescuePlan #PaidLeave #BlackHealth

About 3 days ago

Follow @ncchurches

Latest Tweets

Dr. Satcher questioned the structures that have upheld health disparities in our communities. By laying the foundation for this work, we can continue taking meaningful action towards promoting a society where we can all thrive. #BlackHistoryMonth @HHSGov @Surgeon_General pic.twitter.com/zrw2…

About 2 days ago

Amen! #MindfulTogether twitter.com/cornerpr…

About 3 days ago

RT @MAHECwnc There has never been a better time to quit smoking and vaping. Protect your health by keeping your lungs healthy! #quitlinenc #covid19 #asheville pic.twitter.com/bKlC…

About 3 days ago

Check out this new resource from @DrugPolicyOrg challenging us to dig deeper and work together to uproot the drug war. uprootingthedrugwar.… #harmreduction #mindfultogether

About 3 days ago

Dr. Julian's work was instrumental to the public health community. We carry his passion as we continue reckoning with our past so that we may continue building the beloved community. Learn more about Dr. Julian's legacy at pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ju…. #BlackHistoryMonth @novapbs pic.twitter.com/JJsm…

About 4 days ago

Follow @healthandfaith

Latest Tweets

RT @greenthechurch Be sure to read Green The Church's COO Kim Noble's op ed, "#EnvironmentalJustice in Focus this #BlackHistoryMonth", in the Texas Metro News! @Kimrenay22 #Austin #DFW #Houston #Texas #SanAntonio #EJ ow.ly/mOtw50DGQnN pic.twitter.com/IPOO…

About 3 days ago

RT @ActionAidUSA To build a truly just, equitable & sustainable world, we need to fight for a new #socialcontract. That means: ✔️ Defending democracy ✔️ Fighting for climate justice ✔️ Building equitable food systems ✔️ Supporting women’s leadership. Learn more: bit.ly/2M8xT40 pic.twitter.com/fEWv…

About 3 days ago

RT @interfaithpower IPL is proud to be a signer on this letter. The U.S. must provide bold and socially just leadership to protect our communities from the impacts of climate change, including the threats to our economy- @sbhendershot twitter.com/RealBank…

About 3 days ago

RT @interfaithpower "This is all of our country, this is our mother. It's difficult to not feel obligated to protect this land" - @DebHaalandNM with a powerful reminder of what she believes in. Her passion is exactly what we need right now; the Senate must #ConfirmHaaland! #ConfirmClimate

About 3 days ago

RT @EPA EPA is proud to join our agency partners as we tackle the climate crisis and build a healthier, cleaner, more equitable future for all. Let’s do this! whitehouse.gov/brief…

About 5 days ago

Follow @ncipl

Latest Tweets

Copyright © 2021 NC Council of Churches · All Rights Reserved · Website by Tomatillo Design · Hosted by WP Engine