• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

NC Council of Churches

Strength in Unity, Peace through Justice

  • Voices
  • About
    • Overview
    • Staff
    • Members
    • Covenant Partners
    • Issue Statements
    • Governing Board
  • Programs
    • Ecumenical Immigration Alliance
      • Ideas for Action
      • Sign Our Statement
      • The NC Sanctuary Coalition
      • Immigration Bible Study
      • Contact
    • NC Interfaith Power & Light
      • NCIPL Overview
      • Faith in Action NCIPL
      • NCIPL Articles
      • NCIPL Resources
      • Upcoming Events for NCIPL
      • Contact NCIPL
    • Partners in Health & Wholeness
      • PHW Staff
      • Mini-Grants
      • PHW Collaborative Pledge
      • The Opioid Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
      • PHW Articles
      • FAQs
  • Priorities
    • Racial Justice
    • The Opioid Crisis: The Faith Community Responds
    • Gun Violence Prevention
    • Public Education
    • NC Sanctuary Coalition
    • Farmworkers
    • Legislative Advocacy
    • Christian Unity
    • Peace
    • NC No Torture
  • COVID-19 Resources
  • Events
  • Resources
    • Publications & Reports
    • Raleigh Report
    • Lectionary
    • Sermons
  • Donate
  • Council Store
  • Show Search

Search NC Council of Churches

Hide Search

The Tortured Truth

David LaMotte, Consultant for Peace · December 11, 2010 · 2 Comments

The following article was originally published on NC Policy Watch.

This article has also appeared in the Durham Herald-Sun and on Patheos.com.

In recent days, the Internet has been abuzz with revelations brought to us by the latest “Wikileaks” disclosure. Thousands of leaked communiqués reveal various officials’ comments publicly, though they were originally intended to be private. Apologies, clarifications and denials buzz around the world like mosquitoes around a child’s head on a summer night in North Carolina.

The United States government is threatening legal action in response. According to Secretary of State Clinton, “It puts people’s lives in danger, threatens our national security and undermines our efforts to work with other countries to solve shared problems.” She went on to say there would be “aggressive steps to hold [them] responsible,” and Press Secretary Gibbs said “This is a serious violation of the law.” Reading those words, however, I couldn’t help but have my attention drift from one headline to the next.

Touring to promote his new memoir, George W. Bush is unapologetic about authorizing the waterboarding of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. “Damn right,” he says enthusiastically. That is problematic for a number of reasons, legal, practical and moral. Those issues are perhaps best summarized by Hillary Clinton herself, though she was speaking on another topic: “It puts people’s lives in danger, threatens our national security and undermines our efforts to work with other countries to solve shared problems.”

It is also unequivocally against the law. The United States is a signatory to the UN Convention Against Torture, which, like all US treaties, has the force of US law. An excerpt from that document reads:

Torture is prohibited by law throughout the United States. It is categorically denounced as a matter of policy and as a tool of state authority. Every act constituting torture under the Convention constitutes a criminal offence under the law of the United States. No official of the Government, federal, state or local, civilian or military, is authorized to commit or to instruct anyone else to commit torture. Nor may any official condone or tolerate torture in any form. No exceptional circumstances may be invoked as a justification of torture.

As for whether waterboarding is torture or not, the National Religious Campaign Against Torture notes that “it is torture under the definition in the UN Convention Against Torture; it was torture under the terms by which we prosecuted our own soldiers in the war in Vietnam and Japanese soldiers after World War II.”

Beyond the legal question, there are practical objections regarding its ineffectiveness—torture clearly does not make us safer. It has inspired extremists to commit acts of terror against the United States, and reduced our standing and moral credibility in the eyes of millions around the world.

Most important to me, though, it is simply wrong. I am not willing to concede that the public discourse should be concerned only with what is expedient. As a citizen of a country which espouses high ideals, and one who wants that nation to live up to them; as a Christian who honors the value of human lives regardless of nationality, faith or other allegiance; as a father, a son, a husband—I care about what is right. Even if the lives, physical and psychological health of foreigners could be bargained to save American lives, as President Bush and Vice President Cheney have dubiously argued has happened, this would not dismiss my concerns regarding the immorality of torturing another human being.

And that is only examining the question of torturing someone who is guilty. Of the nearly 800 prisoners who have been brought to Guantanamo, the majority have been released without charges. How many of those were entirely innocent?

Which brings us back to Wikileaks. The New York Times reported that among the leaked documents is one that acknowledges “a bungled operation in which an innocent German citizen with the same name as a suspected militant was mistakenly kidnapped and held for months in Afghanistan.”

Guantanamo and Afghanistan may seem far away when we read about them in the news. Yet many of the men disappeared to offshore torture chambers were taken there about planes headquartered in Smithfield, NC. In spite of excellent documentation and the tireless efforts of North Carolina activists at NC Stop Torture Now, there has been no known official investigation at any level of government.

The release of classified communications by Wikileaks is a complicated issue-legally, ethically and diplomatically. Perhaps, then, we should start with an issue that is a bit clearer. President Bush proudly admits that he has broken the law. Mr. Gibbs, to use your own words, “this is a serious violation of the law.”  Secretary Clinton, will there be “aggressive steps to hold [him] responsible”?

David LaMotte is the Program Associate for Peace at the North Carolina Council of Churches, and is a Rotary World Peace Fellow.

Filed Under: Blog, In the Media Tagged With: Human Rights, Peace

David LaMotte, Consultant for Peace

About David LaMotte, Consultant for Peace

Reader Interactions

More Like This

Raleigh Report – March 11, 2019
Time to Take a Knee
Police Brutality is not a Joking Matter

Comments

  1. AvatarDick Medary says

    January 3, 2011 at 10:11 am

    Torture is certainly distasteful. Everyone would admit that. And certainly, torture for torture’s sake is to be totally repudiated. But what about the mass murder of 3000 innocent people? And what if the only means of preventing that would have been from information received by waterboarding? Is it really that clear that pain and discomfort inflicted, with no permanent psychological or physical damage, on a murderer is not justified if it is for the greater good? It shouldn’t be. Certainly the saving of countless innocent lives is for the greater good. God Himself allowed far worse torture on His own Son for the greater good. Should we tell God that He is wrong? I cannot believe that God does not ever want us to a distasteful thing for any reason during our lifetime.

    As far as waterboarding being illegal, there have been investigations into that very question. The findings have not determined that this action is illegal (http://judiciary.house.gov/hearings/pdf/DAGMargolisMemo100105.pdf )

    Reply
  2. AvatarIsaac says

    December 13, 2010 at 4:08 pm

    Thanks for writing about this, David. Great piece.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Anonymous comments or comments that target individuals will not be posted (please include your first and last name). All comments must be on topic and respectful. Comments will not be posted until they have been reviewed by a moderator. Comments do not reflect the positions of the NC Council of Churches.

Footer

Contact

NC Council of Churches
27 Horne St.
Raleigh, NC 27607
(919) 828-6501
info@ncchurches.org

Facebook

Partners in Health and Wholeness

Featured

The Tortured Truth

Latest Tweets

We are excited to have 2 climate justice advocates join our team this spring as interns, Noely Bernier and Dani Bahena Bustos! Please take a moment to read Noely and Dani’s stories, and join us in welcoming them to our team! ncchurches.org/2021/…

About 14 hours ago

Join @NCJews4Justice for a webinar tonight discussing the Wilmington Coup of 1898. Speakers and participants will be drawing lessons from the coup to the current political moment we find ourselves in. Follow the link to register. carolinajewsforjusti…

Yesterday

"Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere. We are caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied in a single garment of destiny. Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly." -Martin Luther King Jr pic.twitter.com/teit…

About 2 days ago

"We know through painful experience that freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor, it must be demanded by the oppressed." - Martin Luther King Jr. pic.twitter.com/cQ72…

About 2 days ago

Are you interested in Christian unity, peace, and social justice? Do you know someone who is? Share this post and stay updated on what is coming up this year by signing up for our weekly newsletter! ncchurches.org/email…

About 5 days ago

Follow @ncchurches

Latest Tweets

“Of all the forms of inequality, injustice in health care is the most shocking and inhumane.” Thank you Dr. King for your wisdom and leadership. We hope to continue honoring your vision for justice and peace every day. pic.twitter.com/hpVi…

About 2 days ago

Awesome things to come this year - subscribe and stay in touch! #MindfulTogether twitter.com/ncchurch…

About 4 days ago

So important and needed. You are so loved. twitter.com/NAMINCar…

About 5 days ago

Join us, @ncdhhs, and @ncchurches next Friday for a webinar focused on the COVID-19 Vaccine roll out. We will discuss the process and how faith communities can get involved. Register here: us02web.zoom.us/meet… #MindfulTogether pic.twitter.com/Nm90…

About 5 days ago

Check it out! twitter.com/CityofDu…

Last week

Follow @healthandfaith

Latest Tweets

RT @CleanAirMoms Happy Birthday Dolly! Thank you for everything you do ❤️👏🏼❤️👏🏼❤️👏🏼 pic.twitter.com/ezOk…

About 14 hours ago

RT @ClimatePower “The science behind climate change is not a hoax. The science behind the virus is not partisan.” —Vice President-Elect @KamalaHarris on the Biden-Harris administration leading with science to confront the crises facing our country pic.twitter.com/nAMy…

About 14 hours ago

RT @ncchurches We are excited to have 2 climate justice advocates join our team this spring as interns, Noely Bernier and Dani Bahena Bustos! Please take a moment to read Noely and Dani’s stories, and join us in welcoming them to our team! ncchurches.org/2021/…

About 14 hours ago

Grateful for your leadership @JoeBiden @KamalaHarris @XavierBecerra @Michael_S_Regan @DebHaalandNM @TimVilsack We offer @interfaithpower prayers & actions of support from @NCIPL @NewMexicoIPL @iowaipl #ClimateConfirm #Faith4Climate #ActOnClimate #TimeToAct ncronline.org/news/e…

About 15 hours ago

RT @iowaipl Learn more about the nominees on how they have been working with IPL's and other faith orgs on fighting the climate crisis in this article put out by @EarthBeatNCR. ncronline.org/news/e… @NewMexicoIPL @NCIPL #calledtoclimateaction #confirmclimate

About 15 hours ago

Follow @ncipl

Latest Tweets

Copyright © 2021 NC Council of Churches · All Rights Reserved · Website by Tomatillo Design · Hosted by WP Engine